The Real MVP of Sharks-Knights? Hint: It Was Not Tomas Hertl

by | Apr 25, 2019

Now that the dust has settled on what was the most mind boggling first-round series and absolutely inconceivable Game 7 between the San Jose Sharks and Vegas Golden Knights, it is time to look forward to round two.

But first, let’s look back briefly on that epic series between San Jose and Vegas.

First Round Keys

It was obvious going into the series that goaltending was going to play a key factor and that certainly came to fruition. Martin Jones and Marc-Andre Fleury were both likewise amazing and awful at different points in the series. Fortunately for Sharks fans, Jones saved his best for last as he was the backbone of the Sharks winning the final three games of the series.

After being as bad as can be between the pipes in Games 2 through 4, Jones shocked the hockey world by flipping the script and channeling his inner Patrick Roy. In Games 5 and 6 he stopped 88 out of 91 shots, for a save percentage of .967. While Jones would let up four goals in Game 7, he held the Knights to just two goals through the first two periods, including one which many thought was deflected in illegally with a high stick.

While Jones’ stunning resurgence and Tomas Hertl’s goal-scoring heroics in Games 5 and 6 dominated the headlines (and rightfully so), neither player was truly the most valuable in the series.


The most valuable player in this series was Sharks defenseman Marc-Edouard Vlasic. Injured in the middle of the Game 2 loss, Vlasic missed Games 3 and 4 before returning for Game 5. In other words, in games that Vlasic played in the series, the Sharks went 4-1. In games that he remained healthy start to finish they went 4-0.

This isn’t to take anything away from Jones, but his impressive franchise record setting 58-save performance was also the best defensive performance the Sharks had in the series. San Jose’s offense/puck possession game obviously struggled in Game 6, but the defense was impeccable. All those chances off the rush, particularly of the odd-man variety that the Sharks were giving up with regularity in the first five games, were few and far between in Game 6.

Again, not taking anything away from Jones making 58 saves in Game 6, but the biggest save he made in the series was the two-on-one stop on Reilly Smith in Game 5. That would have tied the game late in the third period just moments after Vegas had cut the lead to 3-2 with a power-play goal. Vegas would have then had all the momentum with the Sharks on the verge of losing the series 4-1.

San Jose didn’t turn into a defensive dynamo overnight, but a healthy Vlasic makes all the difference in the world. Brent Burns and Erik Karlsson are offensive juggernauts, but they have their lapses in judgment and often take risks that don’t pan out. The Sharks need Vlasic, he is unlike almost any other defenseman in the world. While he had a down year this season, Vlasic improved in the second half. After falling as low as a minus-16 in late December, Vlasic finished the season plus-10 the rest of the way to finish overall at minus-6.

Despite all the scoring the Knights did in this series, in the games that Vlasic started and finished, he combined for a plus-2 rating. While not quite what he was a few years ago when the Sharks went to the Stanley Cup final, Vlasic is still the same type of guy who was able to shut down the likes of Anze Kopitar, Tyler Toffoli, Filip Forsberg, Vladimir Tarasenko and Sidney Crosby in the 2016 playoffs. Recall the Penguins’ third line, the “HBK line” of Carl Hagelin, Nick Bonino and Phil Kessel is the group that torched the Sharks in that series. Vlasic finished the series plus-1. Sidney Crosby had no goals and just two assists through the first five games of that series. Vlasic had a lot to do with that.

Round 2 Outlook:

For now, as the Sharks move forward in the playoffs, Vlasic will likely maintain his role as MVP. The most skilled forward that will take the ice in the second round series between the Sharks and the Colorado Avalanche is the Avs’ Nathan MacKinnon. The sixth-year forward finished the regular season with 99 points, a second-straight career high. A year ago he finished with 97 points. He was injured for the All Star Game and therefore did not compete in the fastest skater competition. MacKinnon is the only player in the league who could potentially knock off Connor McDavid as the fastest in the league.

Just like it was key for the Sharks not to feed the Vegas Knights’ transition, it will be imperative they likewise don’t feed the Avalanche transition. MacKinnon is most dangerous when he can use that blazing speed off the rush. It will be up to Vlasic to shut him down. Fortunately for the Sharks, Vlasic is quite capable. When most hockey fans think of strong defensive defensemen, skating speed isn’t what comes to mind. Skating however is one of Vlasic’s strengths. That’s what makes him so special is he can back skate and keep up with a guy like MacKinnon off the rush and on stops and starts in the corners.

Prediction: Sharks in 5

Anaheim Ducks Take the Long View

Anaheim Ducks Take the Long View

The Anaheim Ducks will be featured 14 times on US national TV this upcoming season. Several other teams are tied at that number, and only Minnesota and the Rangers have more national games, at 15. The Ducks didn’t make the playoffs last year, and by most accounts, won’t do so again this season. So why all the attention?

read more
LA Kings’ Style Not Flashy

LA Kings’ Style Not Flashy

The LA Kings knew they were going to make the playoffs last season, even though most other people thought they would not. They proved naysayers wrong, and took on Edmonton in round one. They bowed out, but not before seven games had been contested.

read more
NHL Future Power Rankings: Predicting best, worst teams for the next three seasons

Are the Avs and Lightning set up for long-term success? Which teams could shoot up the standings soon? How do teams with young stars fit in? [...]

Matt Boldy, Marco Rossi leading the next wave for the Wild

With several Minnesota players entering their prime, the two young skaters are part of the group that can drive the club to new heights. [...]

Canucks' Boeser (hand) to miss 3 to 4 weeks

Canucks winger Brock Boeser underwent hand surgery after injuring himself Saturday during training camp. [...]

Canada drops vax mandate for athletes, visitors

The Canadian government confirmed Monday it will no longer require COVID-19 vaccines or the use of masks for visiting athletes and other noncitizens as part of relaxed travel measures that… [...]

Golden Knights say center Patrick out for season

Vegas Golden Knights center Nolan Patrick will miss the 2022-23 season, the team announced on Thursday. [...]

Flyers assume defenseman Ellis to miss season

The Flyers expect that defenseman Ryan Ellis will miss the season with a back injury. [...]

Blackhawks' Kane: Trade rumors are just rumors

Patrick Kane thinks rumors of him being traded by the rebuilding Blackhawks are just rumors. [...]

Rinne rejoins Preds as special alumni adviser

The Predators have brought back Pekka Rinne in a new role as a special alumni advisor. [...]

Czech govt. to NHL: Don't bring Russian players

The Predators and Sharks, who are set to play in the Czech capital of Prague next month, have been told their Russian players are not welcome in the country. [...]

Stanley Cup finalists, first coach fired, Kane trade destination: Bold predictions for all 32 NHL teams

With opening night approaching on Oct. 11, we take big swings on what will transpire in the 2022-23 season. [...]

Ever wonder what it would be like if your everyday car was a ZAMBONI?!?!?

Wonder no longer…

Check out The Zambonis' latest hit, "Slow Whip"!